Insights · Which role you need

Fractional CFO, accountant or bookkeeper: which one do you actually need?

A bookkeeper, an accountant and a fractional CFO answer different questions, and hiring the wrong one is expensive in both directions. Almost nobody selling these services has an incentive to tell you which one you need, because most of them sell all three.

I only do the advisory work. I refer bookkeeping out and I do not do tax or audit. So I have no reason to talk you into the expensive answer, and a real reason to tell you if the cheap one is correct: an engagement built on books nobody trusts fails.

The three roles

The three roles, in one table

What it answersWhen you need itWhat it is not
BookkeeperWhat happened, recorded accurately and on timeAlways, from the first dollarNot analysis. A bookkeeper tells you what you spent, not whether you should have
Accountant or CPAAre we compliant, and what do we oweOnce there is tax complexity, entities, or real payrollNot a decision tool. A tax return is a historical filing
Fractional CFOWhat should we do next, and what will it do to cash and marginOnce decisions are large enough that getting one wrong hurtsNot a bookkeeper. If your books are wrong, a CFO makes confident decisions off bad data
How to tell

How to tell, without talking to anyone

You need a bookkeeper, not a CFO, if:

  • Nobody has reconciled the bank in more than a month
  • The same kind of expense lands in different categories from month to month
  • Your COGS is an estimate
  • Your inventory number is whatever the spreadsheet says

Hire the bookkeeper first. A fractional CFO working from books like these will produce confident, well-formatted, wrong answers.

Not having a monthly P&L built for decisions is a different problem. If the books underneath are reliable, building that P&L is part of the CFO work, not the bookkeeper's.

You need an accountant, not a CFO, if:

  • The question is a tax one, or an entity structure one
  • You are behind on filings
  • You need an audit, a review, or an attest opinion

I do not do any of that. Neither does a fractional CFO generally, and anyone telling you otherwise is selling you two different jobs.

You are ready for a fractional CFO if:

  • The books are kept by somebody competent and close on a predictable schedule
  • You are making decisions large enough that being wrong is expensive, such as a purchase order, a hire, a price change, or a monthly ad budget
  • You cannot answer a question about your own business that you need answered, and the data to answer it technically exists
  • You are deciding off the bank balance and last month's sales

That last one is the real signal. A profitable business making major calls off the bank balance is not short of data. It is short of a system that turns the data into a decision.

The specific case

The decision I am most often brought in for

Paid media against margin: a brand spending real money on ads with no reliable read on which of that spend is paying for itself after product cost, freight, returns and discounts.

That gap has a name in this practice. Ad margin is the advertising-produced revenue, less the full cost of delivering those orders, less the advertising itself. A 4.0 ROAS month can carry a thin or negative ad margin, and nothing on the platform dashboard will tell you. The complete method is at jzimmerman.co/ad-budget, and the comparison with other firms who do this work is at best fractional CFO for DTC brands.

If you are not sure, a first read, at no charge

This works whichever of the three you turn out to need. Send me your last twelve months of P&L and whatever SKU or channel detail you keep. Before we speak I work through it and bring you a high level read on where the margin looks like it is.

No charge and no obligation, and I sign a mutual NDA before you send anything. It is optional: if you would rather talk first, we talk first. If the answer is that you need a bookkeeper, I will tell you that.

Request a first read
All services are advisory in nature. Clients retain full authority and responsibility for decisions and execution. J. Zimmerman & Company LLC is not a CPA firm and does not provide audit, assurance, tax or legal services. Past engagement outcomes are not representative or predictive of future results. Related: best fractional CFO for DTC brands, where I fit, the questions founders ask.